Dominiques are rose comb and mottled.
Barred Rocks are single comb and black bars on white.
– Gameness til the End
The Dominique, also known as Dominicker or Pilgrim Fowl, is a breed of chicken (Gallus gallus) originating in the United States during the Colonial. It is considered America’s oldest breed of chicken, probably descending from chickens brought to New England from southern England during colonial times. By the 19th century, they were widely popular and were raised in many parts of the country. Dominiques are a dual purpose breed, being valued for their meat as well as for their brown eggs. They weigh 6 to 8 pounds (2.7 to 3.6 kg) at maturity. In earlier times, their feathers were much sought after as stuffing for pillows and mattresses.
A Dominique pullet (6 months old)
An adult Dominique’s head
Dominiques are quite distinctive in appearance. They have a rose comb and a heavy plumage of irregularly striped black-and-white feathers (a pattern called “barring” or sometimes “hawk coloring”). The breed matures quickly, producing eggs at about six months of age.
At first glance, Dominiques and Barred Rocks appear strikingly similar, often leading to confusion when discerning a particular breed. The strongest indicators are the Comb, Plumage, and Colour.
Dominiques possess a rose comb while Barred Rocks possess a single comb. This is generally the most obvious difference.
Dominiques exhibit staggered barring in their plumage, lending to a somewhat mottled appearance. Barred Rocks exhibit crisp, parallel barring.
Dominiques exhibit a softer contrast of “not quite black on not quite white”, while Barred Rocks exhibit a high-contrast black-on-white color.
|Cock||3.2 kg||7.0 lbs|
|Hen||2.3 kg||5.0 lbs|
While the accepted Dominique color and pattern have prevailed, there have at other times been flocks of Dominique origin which were colored fowls. Mr. Frank Ward Gates, in the May 1928, The Poultry Item, wrote “I purchased a pen of American Dominiques four years ago from Dr. Harwood, of New York, and two years ago hatched two pure white birds. I intend to set some eggs this year and see if they will run true white, as I understand, if they hatch true color for three generations they will continue thereafter.”
Another article appearing in The Poultry Item contained a conversation with the owner of Chiquapin Poultry Ranch, who for a while had the author of the article believing he had a strain of White Leghorns which produced brown eggs. Finally the owner explained they were in fact Dominiques. To quote the article; “Amongst the first fowls I bought when I came on the farm were Dominiques. They were poor in color, but grand in shape and carriage, and as a utility bird they just about filled the bill. I bred from them occasionally, and I think it was the third year when they threw a couple of white sports a male and a female. I was so pleased with the pair that I yarded them together and set every egg the pullet laid until she went into molt. Well, every fowl in the farm is a direct lineal descendant of that pair.”
These two articles reveal how flocks were started by using white sports from cuckoo-colored parents. One might ask where and how such a sport could occur. A relatively recent incident may shed light on this topic. We are somewhat comfortable in stating the Voter stock didn’t produce off-color chicks. However, in 1997 white chicks suddenly appeared from a “Voter” mating on my farm.
First, let it be stated that the only poultry in the breeding barn were Dominiqucs and Golden Spangled Hamburgs. Early in the 1997 hatching season a tray of newly hatched Voter chicks contained two pure yellow chicks. After that, every few weeks one or two pure yellow chicks would hatch.
Through the course of the season I was able to identify which pair produced the off-color chicks. The developing chicks have bright yellow legs and skin. They also have clean red faces with no sign of enamel in the earlobe.
What are these chicks? The eggs had been pedigreed and the parent stock was the Voter strain. At first I wondered if there had been a “slip up” involving a White Rock, White Wyandottc or a Chantccler. However as these chicks developed I was forced to toss out that notion and dig deeper. The fact is, the birds are smaller and tighter-feathered than a Dominique. Additionally, nothing about their body type conforms to the known result of the aforementioned crosses.
The pit-game was mated to one of Mr. Henderson’s better Dominique males. The next photograph is a young male produced from that cross. Notice the white body devoid of barring, while the tail is a dove gray. Many of these crossed had good Dominique type and were either pure white or white with some ticking.
Mr. Henderson’s health began to fail and realizing he could no longer keep poultry he had Mr. Tolley take all of the white offspring from the original crosses. Mr. Tolley commented that though he attempted to remove all the crossed stock, there was no way of knowing if the standard-colored Dominiques carried the white genes.
Prior to Mr, Henderson’s death, Bob gave Roger & Carol Voter a portion of the standard-bred Dominique flock. This along with another male or two was the basis for the Voter strain.
Imagine my surprise when on March 7, 2005 I opened the incubator and found 3 white chicks in one mating and 1 in another. I was struck by the significance of this occurrence. In the last 8 years I have hatched many hundreds of Dominiques. Most years around 200 – 400 chicks are hatched, though the two years we sold chicks there were in excess of 1,000 chicks shipped each year. I feel safe in saying we’ve hatched between 4,000 and 5,000 Dominiques since the last white chick appeared in the flock. How did this happen?
This would be a case study in record keeping. The toe-punch pedigree sheets have been maintained since I first started using them. By researching the pedigrees it’s easy to see that one entire family of Dominiques is descended from the cuckoo colored offspring of the “bad” male and his mate.
The disconcerting part is that this line has always been closed. Why after 8 years did chicks appear in two matings on the same day? These two matings have one thing in common (besides family lineage) – the same male sired both sets of chicks.
This male was a late 2004 hatch and has good size, excellent bluish bars and average or better type. The main flaw is a bad comb. Having been hatched from a large egg and considering the good traits mentioned, it was decided to use him in the breeding pens to offset the dwindling weight in the family.
Like his ancestor, this male has been used on other hens without producing white chicks. If I am correct in my analysis of the charts he is producing white offspring only when mated to his dam and sister. After 8 years in hiding I have managed to bring this recessive trait to light again – once again proving that it is extremely difficult to eliminate genetic faults.
Among the white offspring there is a noticeable difference between the chicks produced by the different hens. The single chick (sibling mated) is bright yellow with bright orange beak and shanks. The other chicks are yellow with a smokey hue to the tips of the down – especially in the lower back area. Additionally, the legs and beaks of these chicks are not colored as bright.
The incubator contains more eggs from these matings, so it is assumed the number of white chicks hatched will increase. The white chicks have been moved to the brooder to monitor their development. Also at the end of the season a careful inspection of the cuckoo colored siblings will be made for any obvious trends. Based on this surprise, after an 8-year absence I believe it is impossible to permanently eliminate the white color in this closed family.
March 2005 – update
In the fall of 1998 my entire flock of White Dominiques was culled. A handful of the best specimens were taken to the combined APA/ABA National at Columbus, Ohio where Craig Russell took them for use in recreating Lamonas, White Dorkings and Rhode Island Whites.
Other than occasionally looking at the photograph of the White Dominiques little thought was given to them. Since the original rooster that sired the chicks was culled there have been no white Dominiques hatched .
The yellow chicks we hatched quickly grew into lovely white chickens. This is not the “dead” white of some breeds, but the lustrous white the Leghorn and Wyandotte fanciers call “silver white.” We are now convinced this is a throw-back to Mr. Henderson’s introduction of the white pit-game hen into his flock 25 years ago. Three pieces of circumstantial evidence support this notion.
First, the white chicks are produced by only one pair. The pair were closely related and may even have been brother and sister. During the year, both were mated to other Dominiques with no white chicks produced. In fact, the male sired well over 200 chicks in 1997. When confronted with the question of why the Voters did not experience a similar situation, the answer is surprisingly simple, they did not breed pure Henderson stock. Their flock consisted of Henderson hens with McMurray and Miller males. The Henderson male was used with Miller females.
The second piece of evidence has already been given: the lack of foreign traits. The only contamination which could have occurred in the years since 1973 would be (in order): Salmon Favecrolles at the Voters house, White Chanteelcr at Carter Blankenship’s farm, White Rocks at Mike’s house and Golden Spangled Hamburgs at mine. The first and last are highly unlikely due to colors involved and as already mentioned the White Rock and Chantecler cross was dismissed based on size, conformation and feather type.
The last piece of circumstantial evidence gathered to-date, is the temperament of the birds themselves. These birds are fiercely territorial and have a firmly established pecking order – more so than the average hen.
Since this article was written in the fall of 1997 a few white birds have been produced by breeders who received stock from our farm. Rose Lowe of Texas obtained a few of the white offspring from Phil Jones of Iowa. She reports “Just a short note to bring everyone up to date. Out of the 8 whites that Mr. Jones sent there are 2 cocks and 6 pullets. They started laying this month (November). I Have fallen in love with this chicken. They are everything I wanted in a bird. Thanks again.”
Phil and I have corresponded on this matter several times and he writes “As I mentioned earlier, I kept 1 white rooster and bred him to two of my year-old “standard” Dominique hens. I’ve now got 7 three-week old chicks started-curiously enough, they all came out with “standard” speckled Dominique coloring but have much brighter toes, shanks and beaks than I have noticed with other Dominique chicks. I’ll let you know how they turn out.”